"Broad comic relief came from Kara Mikula as Sister Mary Patrick; Belinda Allyn as postulant Sister Mary Robert; and Paper Mill favorite John Treacy Egan as Monsignor O’Brien."

"The singing is full-throated and virtuosic. The choreography dazzles. The choir scenes in the church are nothing short of an utter joy … The Paper Mill’s cast is certainly full of top-notch singers who show off a considerable range."

"Kara Mikula as the enthusiastic and bouncy Sister Mary Patrick [and] Diane J. Findley as the angrily displaced head of the choir bring humor, pathos, and, most importantly, strong show-stopping voices to their roles."

"This joyous filled production has amazingly divine individual performances. This is one angelically blessed cast."

"The show peaked in dynamic soul-searching second-act numbers by the convent’s stuffy but ultimately sympathetic Mother Superior (Jennifer Allen) and young, inexperienced Sister Mary Robert (Belinda Allyn)."

"There's so much to love about the dynamic cast. The members capture their distinctive roles, perform the musical numbers with verve, and they have impeccable comedic timing that keeps you enjoying every minute of the show."